Legal updates and opinions
News / News
Can you terminate an employee’s fixed-term contract by relying on the termination provision of a contract of employment?
By Jacques van Wyk, Director and Yusha Davidson, Candidate Attorney
ISSUE
Can an employer rely on the termination provision of an employment contract to terminate an employee’s fixed-term contract without reason and without a hearing?
SUMMARY
The termination of a fixed-term contract before its expiry constitutes a repudiation, which amounts to a dismissal. The dismissal must thus be effected in a procedurally and substantively fair manner.
COURT’S DECISION
In the case of Keith-Bandath v Rhodes University [2018] 4 BALR 377 (CCMA), the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (“CCMA”) had to determine whether the employee, Rasheed Keith-Bandath, was dismissed by the employer, Rhodes University. The employee was employed by Rhodes University on a fixed-term contract. The employer terminated the employee’s contract, based on a clause of the employment contract that provides that the temporary appointment shall be terminable by two calendar weeks’ written notice. The employee argued that there was no procedure followed before his termination and no reason was given for the termination. The employee submitted that the right not to be unfairly dismissed cannot be negated by a fixed-term contract. The employee sought payment of the remainder of his contract period as relief.
The employer relied on the case of Lottering and others v Stellenbosch Municipality [2010] 12 BLLR 1306 (LC) to submit that the employer was entitled to terminate the contract on the basis of the contract itself. The Commissioner noted that the Lottering case was distinct, as it concerned the resignation of employees who were employed under a fixed-term contract by the municipality.
The employee relied on the case of Buthelezi v Municipal Demarcation Board (2004) 25 ILJ 2317 (LAC), wherein the Labour Appeal Court held that it was unfair for the employer to cancel a fixed term contract unilaterally during its currency in the absence of a material breach of the contract. The Labour Appeal Court concluded that the termination of the contract in these circumstances was unfair and constituted an unfair dismissal. The Commissioner held that the authority in Buthelezi was applicable to the current case. The Commissioner concluded that the employee was dismissed and that his dismissal was procedurally and substantively unfair. The Commissioner ordered the employer to pay the employee the salary for the remainder of his contract period.
IMPORTANCE OF THIS CASE
An employer may not rely on a termination clause in a fixed-term employment contract to justify the termination of an employee, as the termination will constitute an unfair dismissal. The dismissal must be procedurally and substantively fair.
Latest News
Reinstatement awards: Valid tender of services survives review and appeal proceedings
by Lisa Appelgryn, Director, and Rekgopetše Pula, Associate The Labour Appeal Court's ("LAC") recent judgment in Ni-Da Transport (Pty) Ltd [...]
Can children be denied asylum protection due to their parents’ failure to comply with procedural requirements?
by Naledi Motsiri, Director, and Tshegofatso Matlou, Associate This question lies at the intersection of immigration control, constitutional rights and [...]
Cryptocurrency fraud demands more than regulation
by Natalie Scott, Director and Head of Sustainability, and Armand Swart, Director The promise of exceptional returns, sophisticated trading technology [...]
Safeguarding business integrity
by Bernard Hotz, Director and Head of Business Crimes & Investigations Economic crime presents financial, operational and reputational risks for [...]
AI Quality Management under the EU AI Act: Principles, Obligations and the Links to GDPR and POPIA
by Ahmore Burger-Smidt, Director and Head of Regulatory, and Boitumelo Khwene, Candidate Attorney "The EU AI Act asks a simple [...]
Confidence is not capability (Part 2): Governing AI in the age of the rogue agent
by Ahmore Burger-Smidt, Director and Head of Regulatory In Part 1, “Confidence Is Not Capability (Part 1): What the Data [...]
