Legal updates and opinions
Search Author
Are raising fees similar to interest?
The tax court, in a reportable judgment handed down on 13 January 2025, considered whether raising fees are finance charges which are similar to interest, and [...]
Tax Amendments – 2024
Introduction On 23 October 2024, when the Minister of Finance presented his Media-term Budget Policy Statement to Parliament, he also tabled various fiscal Bills. In this [...]
CFC Rules and SA Dividends – A Trap for the Unwary
Introduction The controlled foreign company (CFC) rules are contained in section 9D of the Income Tax Act, 1962 (the Act) and are designed as an anti-avoidance provision [...]
Managing Tax Risks Through Tax Indemnity Insurance
Taxpayers have multiple tax risk management options at their disposal when entering into complex transactions with each option having its own advantages and disadvantages. The complexity [...]
Court orders un-redacted documents be provided to SARS
Section 46 of the Tax Administration Act, 2011 (TAA) allows SARS to request 'relevant material' in relation to a taxpayer for the purposes of administering a [...]
SARS Binding Private Ruling 399: Replacing an asset shortly after its acquisition under an asset-for-share transaction
and Luke Magerman, Candidate Attorney A recent ruling published by SARS deals with the anti-avoidance implications of the disposal of an asset by a company shortly [...]
Tax Amendments 2023
DOWNLOAD PDF On 1 November 2023, when the Minister of Finance presented his Medium Term Budget Policy Statement to Parliament, he also tabled various fiscal Bills. [...]
National Treasury sees the light regarding foreign employers
The latest feedback received from National Treasury regarding the proposal to require foreign employers to register for employees' tax (Pay-As-You-Earn) has been significantly watered down but [...]
“All change is good”: potential implications of the proposed changes to taxation of income subject to withholding taxes awarded by South African trusts to foreign beneficiaries
and Benedict Ngobeni - Candidate Attorney Reviewed by Ernest Mazansky - Director, Werksmans Tax (Proprietary) Limited Currently, income arising in a South African trust that is [...]
Proposed draft legislation to replace Practice Note 31 of 1994
An indispensable requirement for the claiming of an income tax deduction is that the taxpayer must be carrying on a trade and the expenditure in [...]
When is an order of a lower court appealable to a higher court?
Until the recent decision of TWK Agriculture Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Hoogveld Boerderybeleggings (Pty) Ltd and Others[1] (TWK) it had become vogue for courts to [...]
Tax Court or the High Court? The SCA weighs in
The SCA recently handed down two judgments dealing with certain procedural aspects of dispute resolutions as provided for in the TAA. The key takeaway in [...]
The Supreme Court of Appeal steps in to protect the rights of dual-citizens
Many South Africans were unaware that, until 13 June 2023, if they acquired citizenship in another country (other than by birth) they would lose their [...]
The Supreme Court of Appeal steps in to protect the rights of dual-citizens
Many South Africans were unaware that, until 13 June 2023, if they acquired citizenship in another country (other than by birth) they would lose their [...]
SARS: Misrepresenting Misrepresentation
As every taxpayer knows, SARS has extremely wide powers under the various fiscal Acts to enforce and collect tax. One of the protections given to [...]
Changes to the tax treatment of trust income awarded to foreign beneficiaries on the horizon
Currently, income that arises in a South African trust which is awarded to a foreign beneficiary during the same tax year is disregarded in the [...]
Hand over the tax records! Section 35 and 46 of PAIA unconstitutional
and Siyabonga Galela, Candidate Attorney On 30 May 2023, the Constitutional Court handed down its ruling in the matter of Arena Holdings (Pty) Ltd and Others [...]
The proper interpretation of conflicting provisions in the Income Tax Act
and Luke Magerman, Candidate Attorney A recent tax court judgment added valuable jurisprudence to the often-litigated issue of the interpretation of two conflicting legislative provisions. In [...]
Renewable energy tax incentives
and Luke Magerman, Candidate Attorney The draft legislation to give effect to the two renewable energy tax incentives announced in the 2023 Budget Speech was published [...]
Trust transparency as a means to combat money laundering: what should trustees know
by Benedict Ngobeni, Candidate Attorney Concerns around money laundering and other illicit financial activities have been gaining traction over recent years, with authorities seemingly chasing [...]
The FAFT, trusts and transparency in South Africa
Over the past 10 years, there has been large-scale domestic and international financial fraud in South Africa. Sometimes, trusts and foundations are involved, including both South [...]
Important legal changes that trustees must know
Important Legal Changes It has been widely publicised that, in an attempt to head off grey-listing, there have been legal changes, two Acts were passed by [...]
When is CTC not available as CTC?: Part 2
In the September 2022 edition of Legal Weks we published an article titled "When is CTC not available as CTC" relating to the proposed amendment of [...]
SARS v Wiese provides clarity on the collection of tax debt from third parties
By Kyle Fyfe, Director Tax Administration Act In a recent judgment of the High Court in a claim for declaratory relief against Dr Christo Wiese, to [...]
Changes to facilitate joint audits by SARS in the pipeline
by Nicholas Fairbairn, Associate and, Kelly Sease, Candidate Attorney (Reviewed by Doelie Lessing) Cross-border transactions As a result of globalisation and the digitalisation of the economy, [...]